922
Lectures Watched
Since January 1, 2014
Since January 1, 2014
- A History of the World since 1300 (67)
- History of Rock, 1970-Present (50)
- A Brief History of Humankind (48)
- The Modern World: Global History since 1760 (35)
- Chinese Thought: Ancient Wisdom Meets Modern Science (34)
- The Bible's Prehistory, Purpose, and Political Future (28)
- Introduction aux éthiques philosophiques (27)
- Roman Architecture (25)
- Jesus in Scripture and Tradition (25)
- Sexing the Canvas: Art and Gender (23)
- Descubriendo la pintura europea de 1400 a 1800 (22)
- Introduction aux droits de l'homme (19)
- Buddhism and Modern Psychology (18)
- Calvin: Histoire et réception d'une Réforme (17)
- The Ancient Greeks (16)
- The French Revolution (15)
- À la découverte du théâtre classique français (15)
- Christianisme et philosophie dans l'Antiquité (14)
- Key Constitutional Concepts and Supreme Court Cases (14)
- Letters of the Apostle Paul (14)
- Egiptología (12)
- Western Music History through Performance (10)
- Phenomenology and the Conscious Mind (9)
- Human Evolution: Past and Future (9)
- Greek and Roman Mythology (9)
- Alexander the Great (9)
- The Great War and Modern Philosophy (9)
- The Rise of Superheroes and Their Impact On Pop Culture (9)
- Villes africaines: la planification urbaine (8)
- Masterpieces of World Literature (8)
- Programming Mobile Applications for Android (7)
- Introduction to Psychology (7)
- Fundamentos de la escritura en español (7)
- MongoDB for Node.js Developers (7)
- Pensamiento Científico (7)
- Greeks at War: Homer at Troy (7)
- Lingua e cultura italiana: avanzata (6)
- A Beginner's Guide to Irrational Behavior (6)
- The Emergence of the Modern Middle East (6)
- Reason and Persuasion Through Plato's Dialogues (6)
- Fake News, Facts, and Alternative Facts (6)
- Karl der Große - Pater Europae (6)
- The Rooseveltian Century (6)
- Exploring Beethoven's Piano Sonatas (5)
- Dinosaur Paleobiology (5)
- Understanding Einstein: The Special Theory of Relativity (5)
- L'avenir de la décision : connaître et agir en complexité (5)
- Designing Cities (4)
- Problèmes métaphysiques à l'épreuve de la politique, 1943-1968 (4)
- The Kennedy Half Century (4)
- Introduction to Public Speaking (4)
- Emergence of Life (4)
- War for the Greater Middle East (4)
- Postwar Abstract Painting (3)
- Découvrir l'anthropologie (3)
- Analyzing the Universe (3)
- The Music of the Beatles (3)
- La visione del mondo della Relatività e della Meccanica Quantistica (3)
- Initiation à la programmation en Java (3)
- Formation of the Universe, Solar System, Earth and Life (3)
- History of Rock and Roll, Part One (3)
- La Commedia di Dante (3)
- Devenir entrepreneur du changement (3)
- Introduction à la philosophie de Friedrich Nietzsche (3)
- Moons of Our Solar System (3)
- Orientierung Geschichte (3)
- Paleontology: Early Vertebrate Evolution (3)
- Western Civilization: Ancient and Medieval Europe (3)
- Russian History: from Lenin to Putin (2)
- L'art des structures 1 : Câbles et arcs (2)
- Art History for Artists, Animators and Gamers (2)
- Introduction to Classical Music (2)
- Galaxies and Cosmology (2)
- The Science of Gastronomy (2)
- The Fall and Rise of Jerusalem (2)
- Søren Kierkegaard: Subjectivity, Irony and the Crisis of Modernity (2)
- Philosophy and the Sciences (2)
- Understanding Russians: Contexts of Intercultural Communication (2)
- The European Discovery of China (2)
- Our Earth: Its Climate, History, and Processes (2)
- Découvrir la science politique (2)
- Introduction à la programmation en C++ (2)
- Géopolitique de l'Europe (2)
- Gestion des aires protégées en Afrique (2)
- Lingua e letteratura in italiano (2)
- The Changing Landscape of Ancient Rome (2)
- Materials Science: 10 Things Every Engineer Should Know (2)
- Highlights of Modern Astronomy (2)
- La Philanthropie : Comprendre et Agir (2)
- The Science of Religion (2)
- Advertising and Society (1)
- America Through Foreign Eyes (1)
- Superpowers of the Ancient World: the Near East (1)
- The Art of Poetry (1)
- Bemerkenswerte Menschen (1)
- Big History: From the Big Bang until Today (1)
- Controversies of British Imperialism (1)
- Age of Cathedrals (1)
- Christianity: From Persecuted Faith to Global Religion (200-1650) (1)
- Narratives of Nonviolence in the American Civil Rights Movement (1)
- Constitutional Law - The Structure of Government (1)
- Contagious: How Things Catch On (1)
- Care of Elders with Alzheimer's Disease (1)
- The American South: Its Stories, Music, and Art (1)
- Programming Mobile Services for Android Handheld Systems (1)
- Animal Behaviour (1)
- From the Big Bang to Dark Energy (1)
- Configuring the World (1)
- Introduction to Data Science (1)
- Design: Creation of Artifacts in Society (1)
- The Law of the European Union (1)
- 21st Century American Foreign Policy (1)
- Éléments de Géomatique (1)
- History and Future of Higher Education (1)
- The Age of Jefferson (1)
- The Magna Carta and its Legacy (1)
- A New History for a New China, 1700-2000 (1)
- The New Nordic Diet (1)
- A la recherche du Grand Paris (1)
- What Managers Can Learn from Great Philosophers (1)
- Introduction to Mathematical Philosophy (1)
- Exercise Physiology: Understanding the Athlete Within (1)
- Physique générale - mécanique (1)
- Subsistence Marketplaces (1)
- Practicing Tolerance in a Religious Society (1)
- Understanding the Brain: The Neurobiology of Everyday Life (1)
- Andy Warhol (1)
- Web Intelligence and Big Data (1)
- Miracles of Human Language: An Introduction to Linguistics (1)
- Learning How to Learn (1)
- Imagining Other Earths (1)
- Vital Signs: Understanding What the Body Is Telling Us (1)
- Développement durable (1)
- Dinosaur Ecosystems (1)
- The Civil War and Reconstruction (1)
- Shakespeare: On the Page and in Performance (1)
- Introducción a la genética y la evolución (1)
- Poetry in America: Whitman (1)
- Anthropology of Current World Issues (1)
- Escribir para Convencer (1)
- Découvrir le marketing (1)
- Créer et développer une startup technologique (1)
- Frontières en tous genres (1)
- Une introduction à la géographicité (1)
- Gestion et Politique de l'eau (1)
- Theater and Globalization (1)
- Handel’s Messiah and Baroque Oratorio (1)
- Hans Christian Andersen’s Fairy Tales (1)
- From Goddard to Apollo: The History of Rockets (1)
- Miracles of Human Language (1)
- Human Origins (1)
- The Computing Technology Inside Your Smartphone (1)
- Intellectual Humility (1)
- Introduction to Italian Opera (1)
- Magic in the Middle Ages (1)
- Making Sense of News (1)
- Introduction to Mathematical Thinking (1)
- Mobilité et urbanisme (1)
- Moral Foundations of Politics (1)
- Mountains 101 (1)
- The Biology of Music (1)
- Oriental Beliefs: Between Reason and Traditions (1)
- In the Night Sky: Orion (1)
- Visualizing Postwar Tokyo (1)
- The Renaissance and Baroque City (1)
- The Rise of China (1)
- Russian History: from Lenin to Putin (1)
- Социокультурные аспекты социальной робототехники (1)
- Science of Exercise (1)
- El Mediterráneo del Renacimiento a la Ilustración (1)
- Igor Stravinsky’s The Rite of Spring (1)
- The World of the String Quartet (1)
- Switzerland in Europe (1)
- The Talmud: A Methodological Introduction (1)
- William Wordsworth: Poetry, People and Place (1)
- Wine Tasting: Sensory Techniques for Wine Analysis (1)
- The World of Wine (1)
Hundreds of free, self-paced university courses available:
my recommendations here
my recommendations here
Peruse my collection of 275
influential people of the past.
influential people of the past.
View My Class Notes via:




Receive My Class Notes via E-Mail:
Contact Me via E-Mail:
edward [at] tanguay.info
Notes on video lecture:
The Progressive Amendments: 16, 17, 18, and 19
Notes taken by Edward Tanguay on January 15, 2015 (go to class or lectures)


Choose from these words to fill the blanks below:
opposite, excluding, people, 1920, each, 1895, sex, corruption, Progressive, slavery, 17th, structural, federal, analysis, low, incomes, embarrassing, alcoholic, optimism, political, judge, unjustified, good, Reconstruction, federal, liquors, half, states, temporary, bartenders, bribe, women, repeal, Constitution, states, process, scientific, not, 1920s, out, good
the Era Amendments
1890s to
they are connected with a kind of about government and society
government can be improved following methods
good government can be a force for
these amendments have interesting aspects of the amendment making process to teach us
constitutional design in general
our in particular
16th Amendment (1913)
"The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on , from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration."
gives the Federal government the power to tax income
there had been federal income taxes before, but they were frequently ones
to pay for wars
rates were quite : 2-3%
Supreme Court decision in made it impossible to administer an income tax
therefore this explicit amendment was adopted
what can we learn from the 16th Amendment?
1. you have to pay your taxes
2. that power continues to move away from the and to the federal government
this also happened when we moved from the Articles of Confederation to the Constitution
it happens again more dramatically with the
and it happens on a smaller scale more or less continuously
3. that the government is going to have more money, and with that money comes power
the federal government does not have the right to tell to pass certain laws, but if it has enough money, it can say to the states: if you want this money, pass this law, and the states usually will
this is no problem as long as the federal government continues to only make laws which should not be left to the states
what would make the federal government hold back from making laws which states should be deciding on?
we know that representatives to the federal government care about getting re-elected, so we will put the power to elect them in the hands of people who care about state interests: the people of the state, hence the Amendment
17th Amendment
"The Senate of the United States shall be composed of two Senators from each State, elected by the thereof."
the reason this Amendment was passed was to prevent :
it's harder to all the voters of a state than to bribe the State legislature
18th Amendment: Prohibition
tells us something about non- Constitutional provisions
it tells us what kinds of provisions we should put in the Constitution
"...the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States and all territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof for beverage purposes is hereby prohibited."
this seemed like a idea at the time, but later Americans decided that they might want to have a drink
and then we needed another Amendment, the 21st, which came fourteen years later, to prohibition
"The eighteenth article of amendment of the Constitution of the United States is hereby repealed."
so the whole episode was a little
it shows us the kind of Amendments we shouldn't have
Prohibition was a bad Amendment for two reasons:
1. we didn't need a solution at all, his was an issue clearly within the realm of what States should be able to decide on
2. this was a very specific policy choice, we do have some of these kinds of amendments in the Constitution that have worked out but they tend to be the kinds of things everyone agrees on, very fundamental principles, no , for instance, or no denying the right to vote on racial grounds
no drinks doesn't quite rise to that level
the 19th Amendment
ratified in
"The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on the account of ."
this amendment teaches us something about how to make constitutional arguments
suppose that the 19th amendment has just be ratified and you are a
there is a law that discriminates against
e.g. that they can't be
how does the 19th Amendment affect your here
the interesting thing is that you can use the amendment to argue for either side
1. the 19th Amendment reflects a view that women are equal, their views count, too, and their opinion is as good as men's political opinion
and if they are equal, states shouldn't be able to discriminate against them by them from bartending
therefore the 19th Amendment means that law is unconstitutional
2. the 19th Amendment guarantees women the vote
women are more than of the voting population
if this is a bad law, if it's , if it's harmful to women, then women can use their political power to get rid of it
therefore, this is an issue that judges should stay of
one they should leave up to the political
and the 19th Amendment means this law is constitutional
how is it that you can take the same constitutional provision and make arguments in directions?
the hard questions in constitutional law are hard because there are arguments on both sides
that's why they give us these great cases, where, usually, you have some Supreme Court justices on side
Spelling Corrections:
admendment ⇒ amendment
Ideas and Concepts:
On the kinds of amendments not to put in the Constitution, via this morning's Key Constitutional Concepts course:
"The 18th Amendment passed in 1920 tells us something about non-structural Constitutional provisions and it tells us what kinds of provisions we should not put in the Constitution:
"...the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States and all territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof for beverage purposes is hereby prohibited."
This seemed like a good idea at the time, but later Americans decided that they might want to have a drink, and so we needed another Amendment, the 21st, which came fourteen years later, to repeal the 18th amendment:
"The eighteenth article of amendment of the Constitution of the United States is hereby repealed."
The whole episode was a little embarrassing and showed that the 18th Amendment to the Constitution was a bad idea for two reasons:
1. We didn't need a federal solution regarding the sale of alcoholic drinks at all, as this was clearly an issue within the jurisdiction of what States themselves.
2. This was a very specific policy choice and so does not belong in a constitution which describes a country's most fundamental laws. We do have some of these kinds of Amendments in the Constitution that have worked out, but they tend to be the kinds of things everyone has come to agree on, e.g. very fundamental principles such as no slavery, or no denying the right to vote on racial grounds. No alcoholic drinks doesn't quite rise to this level."
"The 18th Amendment passed in 1920 tells us something about non-structural Constitutional provisions and it tells us what kinds of provisions we should not put in the Constitution:
"...the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States and all territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof for beverage purposes is hereby prohibited."
This seemed like a good idea at the time, but later Americans decided that they might want to have a drink, and so we needed another Amendment, the 21st, which came fourteen years later, to repeal the 18th amendment:
"The eighteenth article of amendment of the Constitution of the United States is hereby repealed."
The whole episode was a little embarrassing and showed that the 18th Amendment to the Constitution was a bad idea for two reasons:
1. We didn't need a federal solution regarding the sale of alcoholic drinks at all, as this was clearly an issue within the jurisdiction of what States themselves.
2. This was a very specific policy choice and so does not belong in a constitution which describes a country's most fundamental laws. We do have some of these kinds of Amendments in the Constitution that have worked out, but they tend to be the kinds of things everyone has come to agree on, e.g. very fundamental principles such as no slavery, or no denying the right to vote on racial grounds. No alcoholic drinks doesn't quite rise to this level."

On how Constitutional amendments can be used to argue in opposite directions, via today's Key Constitutional Concepts course:
"The 19th Amendment, ratified in 1920, stated that "the right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on the account of sex" which not only gave women the right to vote, but teaches us something about how to make constitutional arguments.
Suppose that the 19th amendment has just been ratified and you are a judge, and you are ruling over a court case regarding a law that discriminates against women, e.g. that women can't be bartenders. How does the 19th Amendment affect your analysis of this case?
The interesting aspect of this amendment is that it could be used to argue either side of this case:
1. The 19th Amendment reflects a view that women are equal, i.e. that their views count as well, and their political opinion is as valid as men's political opinion. And if women's opinions are equal, then states shouldn't be able to discriminate against them by excluding them from bartending, therefore the 19th Amendment means that this law is unconstitutional.
2. The 19th Amendment guarantees women the right to vote and women are more than half of the voting population. If this is a bad law, if it's unjustified, if it's harmful to women, then women can use their political power to get rid of it. Therefore, this is an issue that judges should stay out of, one they should leave up to the political voting process, and so the 19th Amendment means this law is constitutional.
How is it that you can take the same constitutional provision and make arguments in opposite directions? The fact is that the hard questions in constitutional law are hard because there are arguments on both sides. That's why they give us these great cases, where, usually, you have some Supreme Court justices on each side."
"The 19th Amendment, ratified in 1920, stated that "the right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on the account of sex" which not only gave women the right to vote, but teaches us something about how to make constitutional arguments.
Suppose that the 19th amendment has just been ratified and you are a judge, and you are ruling over a court case regarding a law that discriminates against women, e.g. that women can't be bartenders. How does the 19th Amendment affect your analysis of this case?
The interesting aspect of this amendment is that it could be used to argue either side of this case:
1. The 19th Amendment reflects a view that women are equal, i.e. that their views count as well, and their political opinion is as valid as men's political opinion. And if women's opinions are equal, then states shouldn't be able to discriminate against them by excluding them from bartending, therefore the 19th Amendment means that this law is unconstitutional.
2. The 19th Amendment guarantees women the right to vote and women are more than half of the voting population. If this is a bad law, if it's unjustified, if it's harmful to women, then women can use their political power to get rid of it. Therefore, this is an issue that judges should stay out of, one they should leave up to the political voting process, and so the 19th Amendment means this law is constitutional.
How is it that you can take the same constitutional provision and make arguments in opposite directions? The fact is that the hard questions in constitutional law are hard because there are arguments on both sides. That's why they give us these great cases, where, usually, you have some Supreme Court justices on each side."
