922
Lectures Watched
Since January 1, 2014
Since January 1, 2014
- A History of the World since 1300 (67)
- History of Rock, 1970-Present (50)
- A Brief History of Humankind (48)
- The Modern World: Global History since 1760 (35)
- Chinese Thought: Ancient Wisdom Meets Modern Science (34)
- The Bible's Prehistory, Purpose, and Political Future (28)
- Introduction aux éthiques philosophiques (27)
- Roman Architecture (25)
- Jesus in Scripture and Tradition (25)
- Sexing the Canvas: Art and Gender (23)
- Descubriendo la pintura europea de 1400 a 1800 (22)
- Introduction aux droits de l'homme (19)
- Buddhism and Modern Psychology (18)
- Calvin: Histoire et réception d'une Réforme (17)
- The Ancient Greeks (16)
- The French Revolution (15)
- À la découverte du théâtre classique français (15)
- Christianisme et philosophie dans l'Antiquité (14)
- Key Constitutional Concepts and Supreme Court Cases (14)
- Letters of the Apostle Paul (14)
- Egiptología (12)
- Western Music History through Performance (10)
- Phenomenology and the Conscious Mind (9)
- Human Evolution: Past and Future (9)
- Greek and Roman Mythology (9)
- Alexander the Great (9)
- The Great War and Modern Philosophy (9)
- The Rise of Superheroes and Their Impact On Pop Culture (9)
- Villes africaines: la planification urbaine (8)
- Masterpieces of World Literature (8)
- Programming Mobile Applications for Android (7)
- Introduction to Psychology (7)
- Fundamentos de la escritura en español (7)
- MongoDB for Node.js Developers (7)
- Pensamiento Científico (7)
- Greeks at War: Homer at Troy (7)
- Lingua e cultura italiana: avanzata (6)
- A Beginner's Guide to Irrational Behavior (6)
- The Emergence of the Modern Middle East (6)
- Reason and Persuasion Through Plato's Dialogues (6)
- Fake News, Facts, and Alternative Facts (6)
- Karl der Große - Pater Europae (6)
- The Rooseveltian Century (6)
- Exploring Beethoven's Piano Sonatas (5)
- Dinosaur Paleobiology (5)
- Understanding Einstein: The Special Theory of Relativity (5)
- L'avenir de la décision : connaître et agir en complexité (5)
- Designing Cities (4)
- Problèmes métaphysiques à l'épreuve de la politique, 1943-1968 (4)
- The Kennedy Half Century (4)
- Introduction to Public Speaking (4)
- Emergence of Life (4)
- War for the Greater Middle East (4)
- Postwar Abstract Painting (3)
- Découvrir l'anthropologie (3)
- Analyzing the Universe (3)
- The Music of the Beatles (3)
- La visione del mondo della Relatività e della Meccanica Quantistica (3)
- Initiation à la programmation en Java (3)
- Formation of the Universe, Solar System, Earth and Life (3)
- History of Rock and Roll, Part One (3)
- La Commedia di Dante (3)
- Devenir entrepreneur du changement (3)
- Introduction à la philosophie de Friedrich Nietzsche (3)
- Moons of Our Solar System (3)
- Orientierung Geschichte (3)
- Paleontology: Early Vertebrate Evolution (3)
- Western Civilization: Ancient and Medieval Europe (3)
- Russian History: from Lenin to Putin (2)
- L'art des structures 1 : Câbles et arcs (2)
- Art History for Artists, Animators and Gamers (2)
- Introduction to Classical Music (2)
- Galaxies and Cosmology (2)
- The Science of Gastronomy (2)
- The Fall and Rise of Jerusalem (2)
- Søren Kierkegaard: Subjectivity, Irony and the Crisis of Modernity (2)
- Philosophy and the Sciences (2)
- Understanding Russians: Contexts of Intercultural Communication (2)
- The European Discovery of China (2)
- Our Earth: Its Climate, History, and Processes (2)
- Découvrir la science politique (2)
- Introduction à la programmation en C++ (2)
- Géopolitique de l'Europe (2)
- Gestion des aires protégées en Afrique (2)
- Lingua e letteratura in italiano (2)
- The Changing Landscape of Ancient Rome (2)
- Materials Science: 10 Things Every Engineer Should Know (2)
- Highlights of Modern Astronomy (2)
- La Philanthropie : Comprendre et Agir (2)
- The Science of Religion (2)
- Advertising and Society (1)
- America Through Foreign Eyes (1)
- Superpowers of the Ancient World: the Near East (1)
- The Art of Poetry (1)
- Bemerkenswerte Menschen (1)
- Big History: From the Big Bang until Today (1)
- Controversies of British Imperialism (1)
- Age of Cathedrals (1)
- Christianity: From Persecuted Faith to Global Religion (200-1650) (1)
- Narratives of Nonviolence in the American Civil Rights Movement (1)
- Constitutional Law - The Structure of Government (1)
- Contagious: How Things Catch On (1)
- Care of Elders with Alzheimer's Disease (1)
- The American South: Its Stories, Music, and Art (1)
- Programming Mobile Services for Android Handheld Systems (1)
- Animal Behaviour (1)
- From the Big Bang to Dark Energy (1)
- Configuring the World (1)
- Introduction to Data Science (1)
- Design: Creation of Artifacts in Society (1)
- The Law of the European Union (1)
- 21st Century American Foreign Policy (1)
- Éléments de Géomatique (1)
- History and Future of Higher Education (1)
- The Age of Jefferson (1)
- The Magna Carta and its Legacy (1)
- A New History for a New China, 1700-2000 (1)
- The New Nordic Diet (1)
- A la recherche du Grand Paris (1)
- What Managers Can Learn from Great Philosophers (1)
- Introduction to Mathematical Philosophy (1)
- Exercise Physiology: Understanding the Athlete Within (1)
- Physique générale - mécanique (1)
- Subsistence Marketplaces (1)
- Practicing Tolerance in a Religious Society (1)
- Understanding the Brain: The Neurobiology of Everyday Life (1)
- Andy Warhol (1)
- Web Intelligence and Big Data (1)
- Miracles of Human Language: An Introduction to Linguistics (1)
- Learning How to Learn (1)
- Imagining Other Earths (1)
- Vital Signs: Understanding What the Body Is Telling Us (1)
- Développement durable (1)
- Dinosaur Ecosystems (1)
- The Civil War and Reconstruction (1)
- Shakespeare: On the Page and in Performance (1)
- Introducción a la genética y la evolución (1)
- Poetry in America: Whitman (1)
- Anthropology of Current World Issues (1)
- Escribir para Convencer (1)
- Découvrir le marketing (1)
- Créer et développer une startup technologique (1)
- Frontières en tous genres (1)
- Une introduction à la géographicité (1)
- Gestion et Politique de l'eau (1)
- Theater and Globalization (1)
- Handel’s Messiah and Baroque Oratorio (1)
- Hans Christian Andersen’s Fairy Tales (1)
- From Goddard to Apollo: The History of Rockets (1)
- Miracles of Human Language (1)
- Human Origins (1)
- The Computing Technology Inside Your Smartphone (1)
- Intellectual Humility (1)
- Introduction to Italian Opera (1)
- Magic in the Middle Ages (1)
- Making Sense of News (1)
- Introduction to Mathematical Thinking (1)
- Mobilité et urbanisme (1)
- Moral Foundations of Politics (1)
- Mountains 101 (1)
- The Biology of Music (1)
- Oriental Beliefs: Between Reason and Traditions (1)
- In the Night Sky: Orion (1)
- Visualizing Postwar Tokyo (1)
- The Renaissance and Baroque City (1)
- The Rise of China (1)
- Russian History: from Lenin to Putin (1)
- Социокультурные аспекты социальной робототехники (1)
- Science of Exercise (1)
- El Mediterráneo del Renacimiento a la Ilustración (1)
- Igor Stravinsky’s The Rite of Spring (1)
- The World of the String Quartet (1)
- Switzerland in Europe (1)
- The Talmud: A Methodological Introduction (1)
- William Wordsworth: Poetry, People and Place (1)
- Wine Tasting: Sensory Techniques for Wine Analysis (1)
- The World of Wine (1)
Hundreds of free, self-paced university courses available:
my recommendations here
my recommendations here
Peruse my collection of 275
influential people of the past.
influential people of the past.
View My Class Notes via:




Receive My Class Notes via E-Mail:
Contact Me via E-Mail:
edward [at] tanguay.info
Notes on video lecture:
Historical Jesus and the Importance of Criteria
Notes taken by Edward Tanguay on November 29, 2016 (go to class or lectures)


Choose from these words to fill the blanks below:
modern, Palestine, skeptical, pagans, cynic, Suetonius, biographers, collections, embarrassment, knowledge, Judaism, Caligula, maverick, sins, divorce, Paul, fourth, patterns, John, reject, accuracy, evangelists, Galilee, scholars, laconic, faith, Synoptic, Gospels, criteria, baptized, single, ancient, attestation, redaction, powerful, bad
what is meant by when they say the historical Jesus?
what are the that we use when we talk decide what is historical and what is not?
what do we mean when we talk about the real Nero or the real , or Reagan or Clinton
what we usually mean by the real person is a body of that approaches an extremely accurate record of every day of their life
obviously, history is a different caliber for determining what is real in this sense
few sources
the idea of objectivity certainly wasn't there for ancient
even the very significant figures are not well known in the sense of
we sense that Caligula was an evil kind of person since people who witness his murders communicated this, but he never communicated anything directly
but we don't know for certain to what degree Caligula was mad, sad, or
once you get past what and Tacitus tell us in the way of gossip, what do we really know?
and this was one of the emperors
for Jesus
once you get down to the totally obscure Jew from who was born probably somewhere around 8-4 BC and lived to roughly around 30 AD, you get the sense that we're not going to have a vast amount of information here
but this is a problem we face with any ancient, historical figure
what we know with certitude about Alexander the Great could probably be fit onto a page of print
and so we have problems here with the historical Jesus
this historical Jesus is the person who can be recovered, reconstituted, and reconstructed by applying tools of historical research to ancient sources
even the mention that what they report of Jesus is a selection of what they knew, and that it was written not for a historical purpose of explaining who the name behind the Jesus name was, but that you may believe in Jesus as a religious figure, which is something entirely different
as with anything written in Ancient times, these texts were written from a very specific point of view
in the case of Jesus, most written accounts must be seen through the carried on by the early church
which leads tot he second question: if the four Gospels are both our major sources and our major road blocks of constructing a historical Jesus, how do you approach them, how do you sift them, so that on the one hand you're not being terribly naive, whereas on the other hand you're not being unduly
Mark
was written around 70 AD
drew upon earlier
Matthew and Luke
build on Mark
but have a separate stream of sayings of Jesus which we label Q
have their own special traditions
John
is very useful contrary to what many people claim
it represents a different tradition than the Gospels (Mark, Matthew and Luke)
was the last one to be written
there is much to much of a tendency to dismiss John
some say 's account of the Last Supper was correct and the Synoptics were not
what criteria do we use to discover the historical Jesus
stage one
the actual life of Jesus himself
stage two
the early oral tradition and the teaching of the Church after Jesus' death
applying Jesus' teaching to unwashed being introduced to it
stage three
the : Mark, Matthew, Luke, and John
how do we move back from stage three, to stage two, and then to stage one
criticism
regards the author of the text as editor of his or her source materials
considers the tendencies of the final writer
criterion
Greek [κριτήριον] for a test, a means of judging
some criteria
what criteria are reasons, rules, standards on which to make a judgement
so what use are your conclusions without these reasons, rules, and standards
so criteria is very important, i.e. to know what criteria you use, when do they apply, in what ways do they apply, etc.
multiple of independent sources
thinking of it as a court room, you need more than one person on the witness stand who did not collude with the witness beforehand
the prohibition of is in
Mark's gospel
Q tradition
Paul is very strong on urging this
was very confident of his apostolic authority
it was typical of him call who speaks in the "I" form
e.g. I Corinthians, chapter 7
but with the prohibition of divorce, suggests that Jesus said it
when he needs to talk about a mixed marriage between a Christian and a pagan, then he returns to his own authority
discontinuity criteria
in mainstream had rules and regulations govern it
that one would prohibit it completely is not likely
the early church struggled with the prohibition of divorce that they were apparently handed down by Jesus
criteria of
John the Baptist baptizing Jesus
with stark and Mark
everything is done quickly and you are left wondering what he meant by it
he says that everyone that comes out to John the Baptist to confess their
then Jesus came to be baptized, interestingly without the further participle referring to confessing of sins
in the later Gospels
feel Mark has not done enough
you have an argument before Jesus' baptism where John says that he should rather be by Jesus
Jesus speaking his first words, says, let it be so for now
Matthew
mathematical Matthew, teaching by way of
Luke goes more radical
has John the Baptist in the infancy narrative
as well as Elizabeth, Mary, Zachary
Herod then puts John in prison
after that, Jesus gets baptized, we are not told who baptized Jesus, and we are told that John is in prison
in the sermons of Peter and Paul where you get summaries of the Gospel stories, but never is ever said about the Baptism of Jesus by John in those summaries
John
the radical Gospel
a different tradition and a world view, almost into Platonism
his radical solution is that it never happened
never says John the Baptist
John is baptizing, but his major function is to witness to Jesus
Jesus is never baptized in the gospel
in fact we find out that Jesus is baptizing other people in an imitation of John
criterion of Jesus' passionate death
how do we explain that this teacher and healer from winds up getting crucified by the Roman Prefect in Jerusalem
he must have said things and did things that threatened people and threatened very people
so a bland Jesus, or Jesus as philosopher, or a Jesus who is interested in mysticism is not very believable
Spelling Corrections:
crusified ⇒ crucified
Ideas and Concepts:
An invitation to discuss what one means by real, via tonight's Jesus in Scripture and Tradition class: "When discussing the historical Jesus with my students, I always remind them that the real Jesus is not the historical Jesus, and the historical Jesus is not the real Jesus."
Historical critical analysis concept of the day via this morning's Jesus in Scripture and Tradition class:
"Criterion of multiple attestation, n. a tool used by Biblical scholars to help determine whether certain actions or sayings by Jesus in the New Testament are from Historical Jesus.
The criterion of multiple attestation focuses on the sayings or deeds of Jesus that are attested to in more than one independent literary source such as Apostle Paul, Josephus, Q and/or the Gospel of the Hebrews. The force of this criterion is increased if a given motif or theme is also found in different literary forms such as parables, dispute stories, miracle stories, prophecy, and/or aphorism.
Multiple attestation has a certain kind of objectivity. Given the independence of the sources, satisfaction of the criterion makes it harder to maintain that it was an invention of the Church.
The criterion of multiple attestation typically one of a number of criteria used in Biblical research, others include the criterion of discontinuity (if a saying attributed to Jesus is dissimilar to the Jewish traditions of his time, it is likely to be authentic) and the criterion of embarrassment (accounts embarrassing to the author are presumed to be true because the author would have no reason to invent an embarrassing account), along with the historical method (uses sources of disinterested archeology)."
"Criterion of multiple attestation, n. a tool used by Biblical scholars to help determine whether certain actions or sayings by Jesus in the New Testament are from Historical Jesus.
The criterion of multiple attestation focuses on the sayings or deeds of Jesus that are attested to in more than one independent literary source such as Apostle Paul, Josephus, Q and/or the Gospel of the Hebrews. The force of this criterion is increased if a given motif or theme is also found in different literary forms such as parables, dispute stories, miracle stories, prophecy, and/or aphorism.
Multiple attestation has a certain kind of objectivity. Given the independence of the sources, satisfaction of the criterion makes it harder to maintain that it was an invention of the Church.
The criterion of multiple attestation typically one of a number of criteria used in Biblical research, others include the criterion of discontinuity (if a saying attributed to Jesus is dissimilar to the Jewish traditions of his time, it is likely to be authentic) and the criterion of embarrassment (accounts embarrassing to the author are presumed to be true because the author would have no reason to invent an embarrassing account), along with the historical method (uses sources of disinterested archeology)."