EDWARD'S LECTURE NOTES:
More notes at http://tanguay.info/learntracker
C O U R S E 
Letters of the Apostle Paul
Laura Nasrallah, Harvard University
https://www.edx.org/course/harvardx/harvardx-hds1544-1x-early-christianity-927
C O U R S E   L E C T U R E 
Josephus on the Definition of Jew and Christian in the Ancient World
Notes taken on February 17, 2014 by Edward Tanguay
•
a study of Paul's letters leads us to a better understanding of Judaism in the ancient world
•
Jews fall into three categories: orthodox, reformed, conservative
•
but this is true of other religious identities as well, e.g. within Christianity you have Orthodox, Roman Catholic and Protestants, and within each of these there are many branches
•
in antiquity it was also hard to say exactly what a Jew was
•
they erected a boundary between themselves and non-Jews, or Gentiles, but the boundary was always crossable and not always clearly marked
•
e.g. if a Gentile were to convert to Judaism in 80 CE, it is unclear who would accept this:
•
local Jewish community?
•
the city's government, thus granting rights and privileges such as certain tax categories?
•
the word "Jew" in Greek is "Ioudaios" and means "from Judea"
•
this is the primary word that Paul uses in his letters, instead of "Hebrew" or "Israelite"
•
later it came to mean Jews who were outside this area, e.g. from Egypt
•
so "Ioudaios" is an ethic-geographical definition that came to mean more
•
Josephus [joh-SEE-fuss]
•
learned about the diversity of Judaism
•
he frames them in terms of philosophies
•
just as Greeks have many kinds of philosophies, so do Jews
•
1. Pharisees
•
live simply, respect reason, respect the old, believe the soul is immortal and free will reigns
•
2. Sadducees [sad-JOO-seez]
•
souls die with their bodies
•
very few accept their documents
•
3. Essenes
•
immortality of the soul
•
do not participate in temple sacrifice
•
have rights of their own
•
have no wives, no slaves
•
Josephus gives them a glowing description
•
like Greeks: bodies are corruptible but souls are immortal
•
share all things in common
•
4. "the fourth sect"
•
Josephus doesn't like them
•
Judas of Galilee was its author
•
attached to liberty
•
God is the only rule and Lord
•
Josephus reminds us that, to be accurate, we can't talk about Judaism or Christianity in antiquity as if it were monolithic
•
there were many groups, interpretations, and conflicting interests among the members of each religion
•
Christians refused to call any human "Lord"
•
in Galatians, we see a hint of multiple kinds of "Jews in Christ", Paul insists that Galatians shouldn't be following "another gospel"
•
Paul was competing with others who were taking the message out and explaining how Gentiles, or non-Jews- may become God's people
•
Josephus also mentions the "spiral of violence" that was ongoing at the time when Jesus was born and coming of age, at the beginning of the Jesus movement
•
e.g. Judas of Galilee who said that people were cowards if they would endure to pay a tax to the Romans and submit to mortals as their Lord
•
many Jews who called themselves prophets and who led Jews into rebellions against the Romans