EDWARD'S LECTURE NOTES:
More notes at http://tanguay.info/learntracker
C O U R S E 
Greeks at War: Homer at Troy
Robert Garland, Colgate University
https://www.edx.org/course/greeks-war-homer-troy-colgatex-gw101x
C O U R S E   L E C T U R E 
How Was the Iliad Poem Born?
Notes taken on June 10, 2015 by Edward Tanguay
•
the Iliad
•
product of an oral tradition, as with the the Odyssey
•
composed over 500 years after the events they describe
•
most scholars believe there is some historical kernel that got preserved in the memory of the Greeks
•
was handed down from one generation to another
•
maybe the war didn't last 10 years
•
maybe it didn't involve the entire Greek world
•
maybe Achilles was just an insubordinate officer who caused a lot of trouble and went on a rampage
•
in any case, the event was sufficiently momentous and traumatic never to be forgotten
•
Mycenaeans
•
the Greeks who kept the memory of the war alive were very different from the heroes of Homer's poem
•
Mycenaean sites and palaces began to be destroyed around 1200 BC, about a generation after the fall of Troy
•
it is unclear way
•
there was a recovery but it didn't last
•
it could be that the Mycenaean destruction was done mostly by the Dorians who invaded Greece from the north shortly after the Trojan War
•
Greeks that composed the poems
•
when the poems were being composed, Greece had become a cultural backwater
•
a place of little consequence to other parts of the world
•
the arts had virtually died out
•
little evidence of communication with the outside world
•
Linear B, a script that the Myceneeans used for administrative purposes, was forgotten
•
these Greeks of the Dark Period, so to say, looked back on a former Greece which could send out a huge force to wage a war
•
"The Trojan War may have had the appeal of an event in which a people is indeed victorious but so exhausted itself in victory that this was its last achievement."
•
the story is shaped by this period of decline
•
had lost all its unity
•
today we may question the historicity of the Trojan War, but the Ancient Greeks did not
•
Herodotus
•
wrote history of Persian wars
•
Thucydides
•
wrote at history of the Peloponnesian War
•
saw the poems at their supreme literary achievement
•
studied and learned by heart
•
recited in public and private
•
we have more scraps of Homer preserved on papyrus than we have from any other Greek writer
•
provided the Greeks with an image of the gods but were not religious texts as e.g. the Old Testament texts were for other cultures
•
first written down in Athens around the middle of the sixth century BCE
•
from then on the texts of both poems were essentially fixed
•
a number of surviving, and no doubt many lost Greek tragedies, were focused around the theme of the war
•
Aeschylus [Αἰσχύλος]
•
Oristia [Ὀρέστεια]
•
Sophocles
•
Ajax
•
chronicles the fate of the warrior Ajax after the events of the Iliad, but before the end of the Trojan War
•
Philoctetes [Φιλοκτήτης]
•
describes the attempt by Neoptolemus and Odysseus to bring the disabled Philoctetes, the master archer, with them to Troy
•
one of the seven tragedies of Sophocles to have survived in its complete form
•
Euripides
•
Hecuba
•
takes place after the Trojan War, but before the Greeks have departed Troy (roughly the same time as The Trojan Women, another play by Euripides)
•
central figure is Hecuba, wife of King Priam, formerly Queen of the now-fallen city
•
depicts Hecuba's grief over the death of her daughter Polyxena, and the revenge she takes for the murder of her youngest son Polydorus
•
Andromache [Ἀνδρομάχη]
•
dramatises Andromache's life as a slave, years after the events of the Trojan War, and her conflict with her master's new wife, Hermione
•
Trilogy
•
1. Alexandros
•
the recognition of the Trojan prince Paris who had been abandoned in infancy by his parents and rediscovered in adulthood
•
2. Palamedes
•
Greek mistreatment of their fellow Greek Palamedes
•
3. Trojan Women
•
the fates of the women of Troy after their city has been sacked, their husbands killed, and as their remaining families are about to be taken away as slaves
•
often considered a commentary on the capture of the Aegean island of Melos and the subsequent slaughter and subjugation of its populace by the Athenians earlier that year
•
the Greeks could never lay the Trojan War to rest, as it raised deeply troubling questions about
•
warfare in general
•
the treatment of the defeated
•
returned to questions Homer raised
•
how can such a war be justified?
•
is the cost of military victory worth it to the victors?
•
as Achilles asks: why do young men sacrifice themselves in war?
•
it may not be in their mind when they set out for war, but once they see what war really means, that question is going to come up
•
Trojan War has been an inspiration for modern Greek writers
•
Constantine P. Cavafy
•
Nikos Kazantzakis
•
Giorgos Seferis
•
poem: The King of Asini
•
in Book II of the Iliad there is a catalog of ships
•
contingents of ships that sailed to Troy under Agememnon
•
1186 ships
•
50 men per ship
•
60,000 men in total
•
shouldn't be taken literally, of course
•
one contingent came from Asini
•
Homer said only of it "and Asini" which meant they were part of the war as well
•
about the search for someone, something long forgotten
•
"Shieldbearer, the sun climbed warring, and from the depths of the cave a startled bat hit the light as an arrow hits a shield: ‘’Ασíνην τε. . .’Ασíνην τε. . .’. If only that could be the king of Asini we've been searching for so carefully on this acropolis sometimes touching with our fingers his touch upon the stones.
•
extends out from the Trojan War conquest
•
to all those who have laid down their lives and are unremembered